
Hello loyal followers. It’s me, Philip Pearson-Batt.
It feels like an age since I last wrote one of these. How are you getting on? Have you been doing nice things?
I won’t bore you with more stories of my trip to Japan, it has quite rightly been pointed out to me that perhaps I talk about this too much. Apparently people don’t want to see your 1673 photos and 29 videos. So sorry for having fun and living my best life!
Obviously, the J-word, has been the big focus of the Pearson-Batt household recently. Other highlights include, booking a holiday for next year the day we got back from Japan, going to see Wicked: For Good (I liked it for what it’s worth and I would risk it all for Jonathan Bailey, sorry Paul) and putting up the Christmas decs.
Normally, I am all in for Christmas. But for whatever reason, I’m just not feeling it this year. I’ve tried everything: Christmas films, Christmas music, multiple mince pies, picky-bit dinners, present purchasing. Nothing is working. So if you have any tips for getting in the Christmas spirit, please please please let me know. I can’t be a Scrooge McDuck!
Scrooge McDuck was a pretty naff employer wasn’t he? Speaking of that… let’s have a look at a recent employment case (classic Philip segue).
This week’s blog is about the fairness of a dismissal involving a disabled employee whose challenges were not properly taken into consideration.
The case in question involved a ward manager named Ms O’Brien who had PTSD, anxiety and depression, and her ex-employer, Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Foundation Trust (C&W).
At the time of the relevant events (in 2018), there were suspicions that Ms O’Brien had not been present at the start of shifts so hadn’t been working her full hours and had claimed overtime for a shift she had not worked. Usually when there are discrepancies in an employee’s timesheet, you’d speak to the employee to get an idea of what’s going on, right? You’d at least think about trying to sort it informally as a step to avoid any unnecessary lengthy processes, wouldn’t you? You’d at least do things at the point you become aware of it because you listen to Precept. Well, that’s not what happened here.
Instead, Ms O’Brien’s manager didn’t raise this with her at the time. They decided to commence a full fact-finding exercise to investigate potential fraud. Ms O’Brien was off on long term sick at the time and following her return (1 whole year later), she was greeted with a formal disciplinary investigation – try not to think about this next time you have the Sunday blues!
Ms O’Brien struggled to recall events, not only because it was 1 year later but also due to her PTSD and therefore struggled to respond to the allegations effectively. She was dismissed for misconduct and as a result, brought claims for disability discrimination and unfair dismissal.
At first instance, the Employment Tribunal (ET) did acknowledge that there was a delay of one year between the alleged fraudulent activity and the investigation taking place and as a result, Ms O’Brien struggled to respond due to her impairments but, ultimately, the ET decided that Ms O’Brien’s dismissal was fair and dismissed her unfair dismissal claim. They also said that her discrimination claim was out of time. Ms O’Brien appealed to the Employment Appeals Tribunal (EAT).
On the unfair dismissal claim, the EAT found that C&W’s approach was flawed. They said that the ET failed to properly consider factors that affected Ms O’Brien’s recollection of the facts and her ability to defend herself. The key factors were the 1 year delay in investigating, the alleged fraud (which was totally out of sync with the Acas Code) and Ms O’Brien’s difficulty in recalling events due to her PTSD. When C&W concluded their investigation, they failed to consider the significance of the delay and described it simply as “unfortunate”. The EAT ruled that C&W’s procedure was flawed as they had not considered the practical effect of the delay. They also said that the ET had failed to consider whether it was just and equitable to extend the time limit for the discrimination claim. So, they have sent the case back to a fresh Tribunal.
As usual, let’s have a think about what we have learned from this one:
- Firstly, this case reiterates the importance of not jumping the gun and considering informal steps. As we always say, a small chat can go a long way (and this instance, save you thousands of pounds in legal fees and save you ending up in a tribunal). C&W could easily have had a chat with Ms O’Brien but instead, they decided to go straight to a formal investigation. Where possible, take a breath, make a brew, sit down and have a chat with the individual before you make any rash decisions. Still make a record of the conversation and follow up in writing so that everybody is clear on what was discussed and was agreed.
- The original slogan is, “don’t delay, claim today”, but if you want to avoid claims altogether, follow the slogan of “don’t delay, act today (or within a reasonable timeframe)”. Bit less catchy. What I mean by this is when there is an issue at work, don’t allow any unreasonable or unnecessary delays to occur. If C&W had approached Ms O’Brien as soon as the discrepancies in the time sheets arose, she may have been able to clarify the situation better. Instead, they allowed a delay instead of doing something today, and before they knew it, they had a claim on their hands due to alleged foul play (poor attempt at rhyming, my bad).
- When conducting formal procedures with staff who may be or are disabled, it is important to tailor the process depending on the employee’s needs or challenges they may face. Ms O’Brien’s PTSD and difficulty in recalling events was a big factor in the EAT deciding that the dismissal was procedurally flawed. Let this be a lesson that a one size fits all approach doesn’t work for everyone. If somebody raises concerns about their health affecting them, then look into this, don’t just ignore it and race ahead. If unsure, speak to OH or get advice from the employee’s treating physician.
If you want to know how you can improve your processes to reduce the risk of having a claim you way or have any general questions, please give me or another member of the team a shout! You know I’m always happy to help.
Call us on 01332 866610 or email enquiries@precepthr.com
Recent Comments